Tipping Point

I used to think of myself as a generous tipper, which basically meant that I would leave more than my dad would in any given situation. I waitressed in small-town restaurants through high school and (partly due to the nature of small town restaurants and cheap tourists, and partly due (I’m sure) to my age and general lack of waitressing skills) never did all that well tip-wise. And by “all that well,” I mean that a $5 tip was pretty extraordinary, regardless of party size or bill amount. Admittedly, I never really had to support myself as a waitress, and any money I made was mine to spend on whatever I wanted… Still, it inspired a sympathy for waitstaff in general.

Now, however, I’m beginning to question the whole tipping scheme. I feel like a penny-pinching jerk if I leave less than 20%, or less than $2-3, even if my bill was about $7. This is all regardless of the service — at some point, tipping became compulsory, and the only relation it had to service was that extraordinary service begot an even larger tip. Last week, for example, my sister and I ate at an Indian buffet. Although the restaurant was nearly empty, we waited several minutes to be acknowledged and seated. The only thing the waiter brought to us was our wine, a pitcher of water, two glasses, and the check (which we actually had to flag him down for, even though we’d been sitting with empty plates watching a Bollywood film for what seemed like a really long time). 15% would have been about $3.75, and frankly I don’t think he even deserved that. But I felt guilty and left $5.

…And this is just restaurant tipping. What do you tip your hairstylist? Your cab driver? The guy who loads and unloads your carry-on suitcase on the RTD airport shuttle? Your hotel maid? Is 20% the new 15%? Is 35% the new 20% (as my generous but perhaps overtipping friend might argue)? Do I need to tip at a coffee shop when I take my drink to go? Does it make a difference if it’s tea or a complicated double skim something-or-other with extra foam? What about when you pick food up at a restaurant and take it home? Or when it’s basically high-quality fast food (like Chipotle, etc.)? How about at a video store? (Seriously, there’s one in town that does have a little VHS-case tip “jar”.)

I’m curious to know what the norm is, and what people in the service industry think is acceptable, good, and horrifically rude.

In Europe tips aren’t nearly as prevalent — you tip, don’t get me wrong, but in many cases just the spare change is plenty, and 10% is the norm (unless I misunderstood and made an ass out of my American self over there). On my first cab ride in York, the driver accepted my tip, but made a point to say that, “you’re a student, love [or “duck” or something]; you don’t need to tip taxi drivers.” I felt weird once in Estonia after eating a much-too-cheap, delicious meal and then leaving about 15% — the waitress positively glowed, and it was almost embarrassing to leave as much as I did (which was probably around a dollar). Of course I imagine that she was getting paid an actual living wage, and wasn’t as reliant on tip-income as our own $2.15/hour-earning waiters are.

Speaking of which, I think waitstaff wages are a major problem — it takes the responsibility of appropriate pay off the shoulders of restaurant owners and requires the already-paying customers to make up the difference. Really, is it our job to give them a raise? And why should it reflect on them if any number of things out of their control go wrong: food quality, wait time, kitchen problems, etc.?

Am I turning into my grandmother (who was thrifty to a fault, we could say), or do others take issue with this as well?



Filed under food, Money, social issues

2 responses to “Tipping Point

  1. I don’t blame you, dahling.

    I am a notorious overtipper, even in inappropriate situations. I think this is kind of like the ‘should I give a hostess gift’ topic. You are never required to do anything. If you start worrying about every facet of give and take (focusing too heavily on the balance), you’ll lose your head…and your heart.

    Generosity should be more spontaneous. If you feel like giving, give. If it’s authentic and real, then do it. If it feels like a strain, then take a cue from your discomfort and don’t do it. I think we are so bamboozled and bombarded with ‘shoulds’ –we have to buy our way into everything.

    We’re getting rid of Christmas gifts entirely for this reason-it was becoming obsessive and compulsive, and not spontaneous. Nowadays if I want to give a birthday gift a month early, I’ll do it. If I decide to send one friend a card and another friend just an e-card, and yet another a 150 dollar gift, I’ll do that…I still feel residual pangs of guilt, but I’ll get over it.

    Don’t let it get ya down, baby!!! ;D

  2. Kris

    I’ve had these same questions. As a bare minimum (if the service was below okay) I’ll tip 15% but if it was good I’ll tip 20%. If the service was excellent then I’ll tip more. I think I read somewhere that tipping 20% at the hairdresser and such places was the norm. I really like my hairdresser so I tip a little more.

    I worked in a hotel as a housekeeper one summer and was gratified whenever there was a tip – be it $2 or $10. A lot of people don’t think about tipping the housecleaning, but having done the work for minimum wages I’ve come to be sympathetic. Really, does anyone enjoy cleaning the toilet and bathroom floor?

    On a related note, if someone is going to stick their kid in a skiing or snowboarding lesson despite the kid not really wanting to learn, that someone had better pay out like one would a babysitter. It’s frustrating, brings the mood of the rest of class down and holds the other students back when the instructor has to constantly be with the unenthusiastic student to keep him/her up with the rest of the class…(there, I’m done venting now)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s